Wednesday, October 22, 2008

Hey there Upper East Siders...

From what I've gathered, most Gossip Girl fans haven't read all twelve books that the show is 'based' on like I have. When I watch the show with others, I constantly find myself saying, "This never happened!" or, much less often, "I remember this scene". Clearly, to translate a book series into a television series takes a lot of re-writing, especially for a series like this, that in writing is laced with four-letter words and excessive sex scenes. I know Rovzar and Pressler have the 'Reality Factor" under control over at NYMag, but to my knowledge, they've never compared the show to the books. Years ago, there was a rumor for a hot moment that Gossip Girl was going to be a movie. I knew I had to find a way play Blair. I mean, who could do her better than me? Leighton Meester, you've done me good. But no one else has. Here's why.

In the book, Blair is cutting, conniving, and classic. She underestimates her beauty and is misunderstood. She is a hopeless romantic and always pays attention to the small details, like hair bows and the perfect lingerie. I see a lot of myself in her, with the exception of the whole bitch thing.

In the show, Blair is all of these things and even preppier than this gal ever could have dreamed. Cheers, LM! It looks as though you are the only one who actually might have read the book.

As for the rest of them...

In the show, Serena is wildly beautiful. She's in love with Dan. I can't say much more. I find her boring.

In the book, Serena is etherial. She doesn't actually walk on ground; she floats. Her beauty causes men to faint. She's free-spirited. She's in love with everyone. Her and Dan date casually for about a week. She's anything but boring. (It should also be noted that I recently read that they are bringing a character on named Aaron Rose as her new love interest. In the book, Aaron is Blair's stepbrother whom she herself shared several incestuous moments with. This should be interesting.)

In the show, Nate is pretty. He's never happy and always pensive.

In the book, Nate is pretty. He's never happy or pensive. He is too baked out of his mind to feel any emotions at all. He lost his virginity to Serena in his parents' bed, not on a bar at some wedding. LAME-O. Now THAT would have been a scene.

In the show, Chuck is creepy, cunning, and sexy. He is, in my opinion, the best character on the show aside from Blair. I'm doubting he read any of the books but he has made the character all his own. And that wardrobe? HOT.

In the book, Chuck is creepy, cunning, and repulsive. He hits on every girl until none of them will have him. Blair Waldorf would not have given him the time of day. He then gets a monkey, carries it around Ross Geller style, and becomes either asexual or gay. It remains unclear.

In the show, Dan is adorable, intelligent, and funny. He is like Josh Schwartz's new Seth Cohen, minus the whole Waspy Jew thing. God, I miss The O.C.

In the book, Dan is anorexic, intellegent, and dry. He doesn't believe in washing machines. He subsists solely on coffee, cigarettes, and bad poetry.

In the show, Jenny is blonde, pretty, and a brat. She's a fifteen year old fashion designer who just dropped out of prep-school. RIGHT.

In the book, Jenny is brunette, unattractive, and shy. She's an abstract artist with one lesbian pal.

In the show, Vanessa is thin and frizzy. Likes to capture things on film.

In the book, Vanessa is fat and bald. Likes to capture things on film. Dear lord, those chapters were downright painful to get through.

In the show, Rufus is a hunky dad who used to be in a cool band.

In the book, Rufus is a washed up beatnik poet who doesn't believe in showering. Damn, they were one dirty family. And I mean dirty as in the opposite of clean.

In the show, Lily van der Woodsen is an ex-groupie who likes to get married. Still holds a flame for Rufus.

In the book, Lily van der Woodsen is actually married to Serena's biological father. Uppety as all get-out. Doesn't know what Brooklyn is or that people like Rufus even exist.

In the book, Erik van der Woodsen is Serena's hunky older brother who goes to Brown. Had a short affair with Blair.

In the show, Erik van der Woodsen was in the movie Spy Kids like ten years ago and has decided to forego a new hairstyle since. Younger and gay.

In the show, Eleanor Waldorf is a bitch.

In the book, Eleanor Waldorf is an idiot. Couldn't design anything to save her life.

Despite this, I am a fan of the show. It's fun, fashion, and follies. In my humble opinion, however, it can't compare to the written version. If you're searching for a fast, laugh out loud read, look no further.

I actually thought that this week's episodes was one of the better ones. Did you all catch Chuck Bass using one of favorite glossary words, Bromance? And Blair's reference to J. Sisters was dead on. Coolest place in NYC to get your wax on. I used to go there... until I discovered Bliss. And realized that I'm not that cool. And her ensemble in the last scene? Perfection.

I must admit that while I loved reading the books, being able to skip around the city in which it's all happening is pretty amazing.

10 comments:

  1. I'm SO glad you posted this because I LOVE GG the show and have often wondered what the books were like. I might have to check them out ;)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you for writing everything I have been thinking throughout the whole show. I started reading the books when I was in the 10th grade. The one thing I am wondering is Blair's mom going to marry Sylus Rose?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I have never read the books. I have watched the show a few times. I could, however, do this same type of review about The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants.

    Why is it that sometimes, the "young adult" books are so fabulous?

    -E

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Brilliant! I have read all the books as well, my sister and I choose to ignore the fact that it's based on the books. It is so annoying. I love that show though, my cousin lives in NYC and I ALWAYS ask him if he's seen them filming, it makes me want to die to just think about passing them film. I love your deconstruction of the book V. the show.

    ReplyDelete
  6. PS I hate Serena on the show, and what is up with Erik?? How do you go from older brother at Yale to get younger brother who tried to kill himeself and is gay. AND AHH they cannot make Aaron Rose a love interest, gross. PPS I love Chuck and Blair in the novels and the show what beats "I'm Chuck Bass."

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thanks for reminding me! I knew I forgot someone! I added Erik.

    ReplyDelete
  8. ooo thanks for the recap! i've been wondering myself!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Wow- I had no idea the books were so vastly different. Sounds like I now need to add them to my ever-growing must read list!

    ReplyDelete
  10. I am SO glad someone feels the same way. I started reading these books when I was in 10th grade (I'm a senior now). I love the show, but nothing can beat the books. I also loved how in the books it would explain why Blair is so bitchy, and would make her much more likeable, for she was always my favorite character in the books. I also was really upset that they made Vanessa all bohemian on the show... I would have loved to see fat, bald Vanessa played out.

    Have you read the new Gossip Girl series- The Carlyles? I don't find the characters as appealing, but I think Avery Carlyle is adorable.

    ReplyDelete